FIRST DATES

First Date Tips for Men

The practical stuff nobody tells you: where to go, what to wear for each kind of date, what to talk about, the check, and how to end it so there is a second one.

By Justin Marc MentoringUpdated 9 min read

The short version

Pick a place you know, keep it to 60–90 minutes and dress one step nicer than the venue. Arrive five minutes early. Ask questions and follow up on her answers, keep your phone out of sight, and go easy on the drinks. If you asked her out, offer to pay: in a survey of more than 17,000 daters, most men and women said men still pay for most dates, even though nearly two-thirds of men wanted women to contribute. End on a high note, and if you want to see her again, say so before you leave.

Before the date: five decisions

  1. Pick a place you have been before. You want to know the noise level, where to sit and what is good on the menu. Somewhere you can hear each other beats somewhere impressive. Our list of 40 first date ideas sorts options by situation.
  2. Keep it short. Weeknight drinks or a weekend coffee, planned for 60 to 90 minutes, with an easy extension (a walk, a dessert spot) if it is going well.
  3. Confirm the day of. A short text in the afternoon: “Still good for 7 tonight? Looking forward to it.” It cuts no-shows and shows you are organized.
  4. Meet there. Meeting at the venue is the norm for a first date, and it means she can leave whenever she likes. Offering a ride is fine; insisting is not.
  5. Have three things in your pocket. Something from her profile or your last conversation, something that happened to you this week, and one good question. You will not need a script, but this keeps the first five minutes easy.

What to wear on a first date

First impressions really are fast. In a series of experiments, people’s judgments of a stranger’s face after a tenth of a second lined up closely with judgments they made with no time limit, and extra time mostly made them more confident rather than changing their minds (Willis & Todorov, 2006). You cannot control your face, but you can control everything around it: a haircut a few days before, a trimmed or tidy beard, clean nails and shoes that are not beaten up.

The dateWearSkip
Coffee or a daytime walkDark jeans or chinos, a plain T-shirt or knit, clean sneakers, a light jacketGym clothes, graphic tees, anything wrinkled
Cocktail or wine barDark jeans or trousers, a button-up or fine knit, an overshirt or unstructured blazer, leather shoes or clean minimal sneakersA full suit (unless you are coming from work), loud logos
Sit-down dinnerTrousers or dark jeans, a collared shirt, a blazer if the restaurant calls for itShorts and flip-flops, even in summer
Activity (bowling, mini golf, climbing)Something you can move in that still looks deliberate: chinos or athletic-cut pants, a polo or knit, clean trainersBrand-new shoes that hurt, anything you would worry about getting dirty
Winter in Toronto, Chicago or BostonA good coat matters more than what is under it, since it is what she sees firstA ski jacket over a nice outfit, if you can avoid it

Two more things. Fit beats brand every time: a cheap shirt that fits looks better than an expensive one that does not. And do not count on the advice to “wear red.” Much of the research on red and attraction looked at women wearing red, and when researchers ran three experiments to test that effect again, they found no effect of red on attractiveness at all (Peperkoorn, Roberts & Pollet, 2016). Wear what fits and what you feel good in. Go light on cologne: one or two sprays, not a cloud.

What to talk about

Aim to listen a bit more than you talk, and when you ask something, follow up on the answer instead of jumping to the next question. Our guide to questions to ask a girl has 20 first-date questions and the research on why follow-ups work. As a rough map:

TopicEasy openerGo deeper with
Her week“What was the best part of your week?”“What made it the best part?”
Work, the human side“What do you actually like about your job?”“If you could do anything for a year, would it be this?”
Travel and places“Where’s the last place you went that surprised you?”“Would you live there?”
Food“What’s your go-to order here?”“What did your family cook growing up?”
Friends“What do you and your friends usually get up to?”“Who’s the friend you’d call first with big news?”
Something she mentioned“You said you’re training for a race. How’s that going?”“What got you into it?”

Leave these for later dates: detailed stories about your ex, salary and money, sex, and arguing about politics or religion. If there is a silence, do not panic. Comment on something around you, or go back to something she said earlier: “Wait, I want to hear more about the dog-sitting disaster.”

What to do with your phone

You may have read that the mere sight of a phone on the table makes conversations feel less close. That claim comes from a 2013 lab study (Przybylski & Weinstein, 2013), but two later attempts to repeat it found no effect (Crowley et al., 2018), (Linares & Sellier, 2021).

Actually using it is a different story. In experiments where one person texted during a conversation, the texter came across as less polite and less attentive, and the conversation was rated as lower quality (Vanden Abeele et al., 2016). So put it on silent and in your pocket. If you might have to take a call, like a babysitter or an on-call shift, say so at the start.

Who pays on a first date

Researchers surveyed more than 17,000 people about who pays for dates (Wellesley College). Most men (84%) and women (58%) said men still pay more of the expenses, even after dating for a while. At the same time, 64% of men believed women should contribute, and 44% said they would stop dating a woman who never paid (Lever, Frederick & Hertz, 2015). Women were divided too: 39% said they hoped the man would turn down their offer to pay (CNBC).

The simple rule

If you asked, offer to pay, without making a show of it. If she offers to split, “You can get the next one” is relaxed and sets up a second date. If she insists, let her, gracefully. And paying for dinner never means she owes you anything.

How to end the date, and the text after

  • If it went well, say so before you leave. “I had a really good time. I’d like to see you again. Are you free next week?” Asking in person is easier than you think, and her answer will be clear.
  • Read the goodbye. A hug is a perfectly good ending. If she lingers, holds eye contact and stays close, a kiss may be welcome; if you are unsure, ask. See how to kiss a girl.
  • Make sure she gets home okay. Walk her to her transit stop or car if it makes sense, or ask her to text when she is home.
  • If it did not click, end kindly: “It was really nice meeting you. Get home safe.” You do not need to promise a next time you do not want.
  • Text the same night or the next day. Short and specific, ideally with a plan. Our second date ideas guide has 30 options built around how the first date went.

Eight mistakes that cost second dates

  1. Running an interview. Ten questions in a row with no follow-ups feels like a job screening.
  2. Talking mostly about yourself. Especially your job, your gym routine or your ex.
  3. Being late. Arrive five minutes early so you are settled when she walks in.
  4. Over-planning. A four-hour first date with three stops puts pressure on both of you.
  5. Complaining. About dating apps, your boss, the city. Negativity is contagious.
  6. Drinking too much. One or two is plenty. You want to remember the conversation.
  7. Rushing physical contact. Let it build, and follow her lead.
  8. Overanalyzing afterward. After a first conversation, people tend to underestimate how much the other person liked them (Boothby et al., 2018). Send the text and get on with your week. If you were turned down, our guide on dealing with rejection will help.

First date questions

What should a guy wear on a first date?+

Dress one step nicer than the place you are going, in clothes that fit well and that you are comfortable in. For coffee, clean jeans or chinos with a plain shirt or knit; for a cocktail bar, add a jacket or an overshirt; for an activity date, something you can move in that still looks put together. Grooming matters more than brands: a recent haircut, a trimmed beard, clean shoes and clean nails.

Who should pay on a first date?+

If you asked her out, offer to pay. In a survey of more than 17,000 daters, most men and women said men still pay for most dating expenses, but nearly two-thirds of men also believed women should contribute. If she offers to split, a relaxed “You can get the next one” works; if she insists, let her. Never treat paying as something she owes you for.

How long should a first date last?+

Plan for 60 to 90 minutes. That is long enough to get past small talk and short enough that you both leave wanting more. If it is going well, you can extend it with a walk or a second stop, but have a natural end point built in.

What should you not talk about on a first date?+

Avoid detailed stories about your ex, salary and money, sex, and arguing about politics or religion. Do not unload heavy personal history unless she brings up something serious first. Keep it light, curious and specific to her.

Should you kiss on the first date?+

Only if the signals are clearly there and it feels mutual. Many great first dates end with a hug, and that is fine. If you are not sure, you can ask. Our guide on how to kiss a girl covers the signs and how to ask without killing the mood.

When should you text after a first date?+

The same evening or the next day. Keep it short and specific: “Had a great time tonight. Still thinking about that taco place you mentioned, want to try it next week?” There is no prize for waiting three days.

Sources

  1. Willis & Todorov (2006). First impressions: Making up your mind after a 100-ms exposure to a face. Psychological Science, 17(7), 592–598.
  2. Peperkoorn, Roberts & Pollet (2016). Revisiting the red effect on attractiveness and sexual receptivity: No effect of the color red on human mate preferences. Evolutionary Psychology, 14(4).
  3. Lever, Frederick & Hertz (2015). Who pays for dates? Following versus challenging gender norms. SAGE Open, 5(4).
  4. Wellesley College (2013). Who pays for a date? Daters have conflicted feelings.
  5. CNBC (2013). Chivalry in the age of equality: Who pays on a date?
  6. Przybylski & Weinstein (2013). Can you connect with me now? How the presence of mobile communication technology influences face-to-face conversation quality. Journal of Social and Personal Relationships, 30(3), 237–246.
  7. Crowley, Allred, Follon & Volkmer (2018). Replication of the mere presence hypothesis: The effects of cell phones on face-to-face conversations. Communication Studies, 69(3), 283–293.
  8. Linares & Sellier (2021). How bad is the mere presence of a phone? A replication of Przybylski and Weinstein (2013) and an extension to creativity. PLOS ONE, 16(6), e0251451.
  9. Vanden Abeele, Antheunis & Schouten (2016). The effect of mobile messaging during a conversation on impression formation and interaction quality. Computers in Human Behavior.
  10. Boothby, Cooney, Sandstrom & Clark (2018). The liking gap in conversations: Do people like us more than we think? Psychological Science, 29(11), 1742–1756.

This guide is general coaching information, not medical or mental health advice. If anxiety, low mood or past experiences make social situations very hard, a doctor or licensed therapist is the right first step.

FREE 1-ON-1 STRATEGY CALL

Want Justin to look at your situation?

Apply for a free 1-on-1 strategy call. Justin reviews every application himself, and if it is a fit he will map out what is holding you back and the clearest next step. There is no charge for the call and no obligation.

Apply for your free call
Apply for your free 1-on-1 strategy call