LOVE

How to Know If You Love Someone

Love, infatuation or just loneliness? Twelve signs, the three ingredients psychologists use to describe love, and what to do once you know.

By Justin Marc MentoringUpdated 9 min read

The short answer

You are probably in love if her happiness matters to you as much as your own, she is the first person you want to tell things to, you feel both excited and calmer around her, and you keep picturing a future that includes her, flaws and all. Psychologist Robert Sternberg described love as three ingredients: intimacy (closeness), passion (attraction) and commitment (the decision to stay). Infatuation is mostly passion; lasting love has all three. Brain scans of people newly in love show activity in reward and motivation areas, which is why it can feel more like a craving than a mood. There is no set timeline. Say it when you mean it, not to get something back.

The three ingredients of love

In 1986, Yale psychologist Robert Sternberg proposed that love is made of three components: intimacy, passion and decision or commitment (Sternberg, 1986). It is still one of the most useful ways to check what you are feeling.

IngredientWhat it feels likeAsk yourself
IntimacyCloseness, trust, being able to be yourself, caring about her well-beingIs she the first person I want to tell good or bad news?
PassionAttraction, desire, the rush when her name lights up your phoneDo I still want her, not just like her?
CommitmentA decision to stay and build something, even when it is not excitingDo I picture her in my life a year from now, and want that?

Mixed together, the three produce different kinds of love. Intimacy alone is liking, the way you feel about a good friend. Passion alone is infatuation. Commitment alone is empty love. Intimacy plus passion is romantic love; intimacy plus commitment is companionate love, typical of close friendships and family; passion plus commitment without real intimacy is what Sternberg called fatuous love (JoVE/OpenStax). All three together is consummate love, the kind most people mean when they ask whether they are in love.

12 signs you are in love

None of these proves anything on its own. Several together, holding steady over weeks rather than one great weekend, usually mean something real.

  1. She is on your mind when you are supposed to be doing something else, and it is pleasant, not anxious.
  2. Her good news feels like your good news. You are genuinely happy when things go well for her.
  3. You want to tell her things first: the funny thing at work, the bad news, the small wins.
  4. You picture a future with her in it, beyond next weekend: trips, seasons, next year.
  5. You want her to meet the people who matter to you, and you care what she thinks of them.
  6. You feel calmer around her, not just more excited.
  7. You see her flaws clearly and still choose her.
  8. You compromise without keeping score.
  9. You worry about her when she is struggling and want to help, not just fix it so you can move on.
  10. You are curious about her, not just trying to impress her.
  11. You want to be a better version of yourself, without her asking.
  12. You have thought about saying “I love you,” and it does not feel like a strategy.

What is happening in your brain

When researchers scanned the brains of 17 people who were intensely in love, from one to 17 months into their relationships, looking at a photo of their partner lit up dopamine-rich reward and motivation regions, including the ventral tegmental area and the caudate. The more passionate people said they were, the stronger the caudate activity (Aron et al., 2005). Lead author Arthur Aron concluded that early romantic love is probably best described as a motivation, a goal-directed state that produces emotions such as euphoria or anxiety, rather than a single emotion (EurekAlert). That is why new love can feel like a craving.

Anthropologist Helen Fisher, Aron’s co-author, proposed that humans have three overlapping systems for mating: lust (the sex drive), attraction (focused, energized interest in one person) and attachment (the calm, lasting bond of a long relationship) (Fisher, 1998). They can run separately, which is why you can want someone you do not love, or love someone you no longer feel much spark for.

One caution: these are small brain-imaging studies of groups. No scan, quiz or chemical test can tell you whether you love one particular person. How you act over time is the better test.

Love vs. infatuation vs. lust

LustInfatuationLove
FocusHer bodyAn idea of herThe real her
PaceInstantFast and all-consumingBuilds over time
Her flawsIrrelevantInvisible, then a shockKnown and accepted
ConflictEnds itFeels like the end of the worldSomething you work through
When apartYou move onAnxious, checking your phoneYou miss her, and you are fine

These are tendencies, not lab-tested rules, and most real relationships pass through all three. The intense early phase even has a name: the Gottman Institute calls falling in love “limerence,” and describes trust and commitment as things that are built in the phases that follow (Gottman Institute).

How long it takes

There is no reliable average, and any article that gives you a number of days is guessing. What research does show is that men tend to get there sooner than people assume. Across a series of studies, both men and women believed women are the first to say “I love you,” but men were actually more likely to confess first (Ackerman, Griskevicius & Li, 2011), and men first thought about saying it about six weeks earlier than women, on average (Psychology Today). So if you feel it first, you are normal. Just let her catch up in her own time.

Should you say “I love you”?

The same research found that reactions to hearing “I love you” depend on context, including whether the couple has already had sex (Ackerman et al., 2011). Timing matters. A few rules that hold up:

  • Say it when you mean it, not to win an argument, get her back or get her into bed.
  • Pick a calm, ordinary moment, not during sex, not drunk, not in the middle of a fight.
  • Keep it simple: “I love you. I’ve felt it for a while and wanted you to know.”
  • Do not demand it back. If she is not there yet, “You don’t have to say it back, I just wanted to tell you” keeps the moment good. If she never gets there, that is important information, and our guide on dealing with rejection can help.

Still not sure? Five questions

  1. If she got a great job in another city, what would I want to happen?
  2. Do I like who I am around her?
  3. Is it her, or is it not being alone? Would I feel the same about anyone kind and attractive right now?
  4. How do I feel on a boring Sunday with her, not just on the exciting nights?
  5. When we disagree, do I want to win, or want us to be okay?

If the honest answers point to loneliness more than to her, that is worth knowing too. If you are in an undefined arrangement and these questions are hard to answer, our guide to situationships covers how to get clarity. If something feels off, read red flags in a relationship.

Does the feeling last?

It changes, but it does not have to disappear. In a later study, the same research group scanned 17 people who had been married for an average of 21 years and said they were still intensely in love. Looking at their spouse activated some of the same reward regions seen in new love, including the ventral tegmental area (Acevedo et al., 2012). Not every couple keeps that intensity, but it is possible, and the habits that help are covered in how to be a better boyfriend.

Questions about love

How do you know if you love someone?+

Look for a mix of three things: closeness (you want to share things with her first and care about her happiness like your own), attraction (you think about her constantly and want to be near her) and commitment (you picture a future with her and choose her, flaws included). Infatuation is usually just the attraction part. Love tends to include all three, and it feels calmer as well as exciting.

What is the difference between love and infatuation?+

Infatuation is intense attraction without much real knowledge of the person: it runs on fantasy, fades fast and does not survive her flaws. Love grows as you get to know her, includes caring about her well-being, and holds up through disagreements and ordinary days. In psychologist Robert Sternberg’s terms, infatuation is passion alone, while the fullest kind of love combines passion with intimacy and commitment.

How long does it take to fall in love?+

There is no reliable number, and anyone who gives you one is guessing. It can take weeks or many months. One thing research does show is that men tend to get there sooner than people assume: across several studies, men were more likely than women to say “I love you” first, and they first thought about saying it about six weeks earlier on average.

Who says “I love you” first, men or women?+

Men, usually. In a series of studies, both men and women believed women say it first, but men were actually more likely to confess love first, and men reported feeling happier when they heard it.

Can you love someone and not be in love with them?+

Yes. You can feel deep closeness and commitment to someone without the passion, which Sternberg called companionate love, the kind many people feel for close friends and family. You can also have passion and closeness without commitment. Being “in love” usually means passion is part of the mix.

Is it normal not to know whether you love someone?+

Very. Love often builds gradually rather than arriving as a single moment, especially if you have been hurt before. Give it time, notice how you feel on ordinary days rather than only the exciting ones, and do not say it until you mean it.

Sources

  1. Sternberg, R. J. (1986). A triangular theory of love. Psychological Review, 93(2), 119–135.
  2. JoVE / OpenStax Psychology. Sternberg’s triangular theory of love (summary of the types of love).
  3. Aron, Fisher, Mashek, Strong, Li & Brown (2005). Reward, motivation, and emotion systems associated with early-stage intense romantic love. Journal of Neurophysiology, 94(1), 327–337.
  4. American Physiological Society via EurekAlert (2005). Release on Aron et al.’s study of early-stage romantic love.
  5. Fisher, H. E. (1998). Lust, attraction, and attachment in mammalian reproduction. Human Nature, 9(1), 23–52.
  6. Acevedo, Aron, Fisher & Brown (2012). Neural correlates of long-term intense romantic love. Social Cognitive and Affective Neuroscience, 7(2), 145–159.
  7. Ackerman, Griskevicius & Li (2011). Let’s get serious: Communicating commitment in romantic relationships. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 100(6), 1079–1094.
  8. Psychology Today (2023). Why men are likely to say “I love you” first.
  9. The Gottman Institute. Situationships and trust (on limerence and the phases of love).

This guide is general coaching information, not medical or mental health advice. If anxiety, low mood or past experiences make social situations very hard, a doctor or licensed therapist is the right first step.

Apply for your free 1-on-1 strategy call