REBOUNDS
Rebound Relationships
Everyone says rebounds are doomed. The research says it depends on why you are in one. How to tell, and how to handle it either way.
A rebound is a new relationship that starts before you have let go of feelings for an ex. Conventional wisdom says they are doomed, but the research is more mixed: in two studies, people who started a new relationship sooner after a breakup reported higher well-being and self-esteem than those who waited, though they also compared the new partner to the ex more. For anxiously attached people, focusing on someone new helped them let go of an ex. Rebounds go wrong when they are about revenge, avoiding grief or proving something. And the popular claim that 90% of rebounds fail within three months has no study behind it that we could find.
What counts as a rebound
Researchers Claudia Brumbaugh and Chris Fraley, who ran the first prospective study of rebounds, describe them as relationships that begin soon after a breakup, before the feelings tied to the old relationship have been resolved (Psychology Today). Two things are worth separating: rebound sex, which is about the short-term sting, and a rebound relationship, which can look serious from the first week. Both are common, and neither is automatically a mistake.
What the research actually says
Brumbaugh and Fraley followed people after breakups in two studies and checked their well-being, their feelings about their ex and whether they were seeing someone new. They concluded that rebound relationships may be more beneficial than typically believed (Brumbaugh & Fraley, 2015). People who moved on to someone new more quickly tended to report greater well-being, higher self-esteem and more respect for their new partner, and felt more confident about their own desirability (Psychology Today). There was a catch: those who wanted revenge on an ex also tended to start new relationships faster, and the faster people moved on, the more they compared the new partner with the old one (Psychology Today). The first study was small, just 27 students who had started new relationships, which is a reason for caution (Psychology Today).
Who you are matters too. Canadian researchers found that for anxiously attached people, the ones who tend to cling to an ex, having a new partner weakened the usual pull toward the ex, and even being led to believe a new partner would be easy to find helped them let go (APA, on Spielmann, MacDonald & Wilson, 2009), (U of T Magazine). But quality matters: later work by the same researchers suggests an unrewarding rebound can leave people feeling more attached to an ex, not less (Psychology Today).
Rebound sex is its own thing. In a study that had 170 college students fill in weekly reports for 10 to 12 weeks after a breakup, up to a third had sex to rebound from the relationship within a month of the split, and people who had been dumped were especially likely to seek it out (Live Science), (Barber & Cooper, 2014). Those motives faded as distress eased; by about five months, people who had been dumped were no more likely than the ones who did the dumping to use sex to cope (NBC News).
The “90% of rebounds fail” myth
You will see “90% of rebound relationships fail within three months” repeated across relationship sites, often next to “65% fail within six months.” We could not find a study behind either number. One major relationship site that repeats them concedes that it is hard to find a first-hand source on how many rebounds fail (Marriage.com), and another of its articles links the 90% figure to Brumbaugh and Fraley’s paper (Marriage.com), the same study whose authors concluded that rebounds may be more beneficial than people think. Treat any precise rebound failure rate as made up until someone shows the data.
Signs you are rebounding
The question is not how fast you moved on. It is why.
| Warning sign | Healthier version |
|---|---|
| You want your ex to see you with someone new | You would date her even if your ex never found out |
| You constantly compare her with your ex | Comparisons come up now and then, and fade |
| You cannot stand a single night alone | You enjoy her company and can also be by yourself |
| “I love you” or moving in within weeks | Letting it build at a normal pace |
| Your ex comes up on most dates | You can talk about the breakup calmly when it is relevant |
| She is deliberately the opposite of your ex | You chose her for who she is |
| You feel numb or frantic when you are not with her | You are sad about the breakup sometimes, and that is okay |
If several warning signs fit, you do not have to end things, but slow down and be honest with her. Our guide on how to get over a breakup covers the grieving you may be skipping.
Signs she is on the rebound
- Her last relationship ended weeks ago, not months.
- She talks about her ex a lot, or they are still in regular contact.
- Things moved unusually fast, then cooled.
- She is warm one week and distant the next.
- She is reluctant to let you meet her friends, or keeps you off social media.
None of these proves anything; plenty of people date again quickly for good reasons. If you are unsure, ask: “I really like you. I know your breakup was pretty recent, so I’m curious where you’re at.” Then believe her answer. If the relationship never gets a label, our guide to situationships will feel familiar.
How long rebounds last, and the “stages”
Honestly, nobody knows. We could not find any study that tracks how long rebound relationships last, and the popular “stages of a rebound” lists are not based on research. A rebound lasts as long as any relationship does: until it becomes clear whether the two of you fit once the breakup is in the past.
At about one month, ask yourself whether you are still thinking about your ex most days. At about three months, ask whether you would choose her if you met her today, with no breakup in the picture. If the honest answer is yes, you are not on the rebound anymore, whatever it started as.
How to handle a rebound well
- Be honest early. “I’m just out of something and taking it slow” is fair and attractive. Hiding it is not.
- Hold off on big commitments for a few months: moving in, meeting your kids, holidays with family.
- Keep your own life. Friends, training, work. A new partner should not be your only source of feeling okay.
- Watch your motives. If you catch yourself posting for your ex, stop and ask who it is for.
- Grieve anyway. A new relationship can ease a breakup without replacing the work of getting over it.
- If it is not right, end it kindly. Rebounding into someone is fine; using them is not. If you find you keep getting stuck on an ex, a therapist can help with the pattern underneath. When you are ready to look for something lasting, start with how to get a girlfriend.
Rebound questions
What is a rebound relationship?+
A rebound is a new romantic or sexual relationship that starts soon after a breakup, before you have let go of your feelings for the previous partner. It can be a fling or something that looks serious from day one.
Do rebound relationships ever work?+
Some do. The research is more encouraging than the reputation: in two studies, people who started a new relationship sooner after a breakup reported higher well-being and self-esteem than those who waited longer. Rebounds go wrong when they are about revenge, numbing grief or proving something to an ex, rather than about the new person.
How long do rebound relationships last?+
No good study tracks how long rebounds last, and the numbers you see online, like “90% fail within three months,” do not trace back to any research we could find. A rebound lasts as long as any relationship does: it depends on whether the two of you actually fit, once the breakup has faded into the background.
How soon is too soon to date after a breakup?+
There is no fixed rule. A better test is your reason: if you want to get to know someone new, you are probably fine to start dating; if you mainly want to stop feeling bad, make your ex jealous or avoid being alone, slow down. Being honest with the new person about where you are matters more than the calendar.
How do you know if you are a rebound?+
Common signs: her breakup was very recent, she talks about her ex a lot or is still in contact, things moved unusually fast, and her interest runs hot and cold. None of these proves it. The simplest way to know is to ask her, kindly, where she is at.
Is rebound sex bad?+
Not automatically, but it is common and usually short-lived. In one study of college students after a breakup, up to a third had rebound sex within a month of the split, especially people who had been dumped, and the urge faded as their distress eased over the following months.
Sources
- Brumbaugh & Fraley (2015). Too fast, too soon? An empirical investigation into rebound relationships. Journal of Social and Personal Relationships, 32(1), 99–118.
- Psychology Today (2014). Can a rebound relationship be the real deal? (summary of Brumbaugh & Fraley).
- Psychology Today (2014). Can a rebound relationship be the real deal? (international edition, on revenge motives and comparing partners).
- Psychology Today (2021). Are rebound relationships always doomed? (on the studies’ sample sizes).
- American Psychological Association, gradPSYCH (2009). On Spielmann, MacDonald & Wilson (2009), On the rebound: Focusing on someone new helps anxiously attached individuals let go of ex-partners, Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin, 35, 1382.
- U of T Magazine. Dating on the rebound (on MacDonald and Spielmann’s research).
- Psychology Today (2014), Dating Decisions blog. The truth about rebound relationships.
- Barber & Cooper (2014). Rebound sex: Sexual motives and behaviors following a relationship breakup. Archives of Sexual Behavior, 43(2), 251–265.
- Live Science (2014). Science: Yep. Rebound sex is real (on Barber & Cooper).
- NBC News (2014). Science: Yep. Rebound sex is real.
- Marriage.com. 15 compelling reasons why rebound relationships fail (on the lack of a first-hand source for failure rates).
- Marriage.com. 6 rebound relationship stages to be aware of (repeats the 90% claim).
This guide is general coaching information, not medical or mental health advice. If anxiety, low mood or past experiences make social situations very hard, a doctor or licensed therapist is the right first step.
FREE 1-ON-1 STRATEGY CALL
Want Justin to look at your situation?
Apply for a free 1-on-1 strategy call. Justin reviews every application himself, and if it is a fit he will map out what is holding you back and the clearest next step. There is no charge for the call and no obligation.